This is my number one, all time favorite place to grab a beer in the entirety of NYC! This historic tavern draws a mix of fun-loving locals and curious tourists alike. Their rotating beer list is extensive and exciting, the house drafts are very popular and they stock a few really exclusive brews that are definitely above my pay grade. Lifting a pint and tapping your foot along to live Irish music is absolutely one of the best ways to spend a Sunday afternoon in the Big Apple.